How We Review Products

Last updated: November 2026

Our product roundups are research-based evaluations. Here is exactly what goes into them, so you can judge how much weight to give our picks.

What we evaluate

  1. Active ingredients and concentration. Does the product contain an ingredient with clinical evidence for your goal, at a concentration that was studied?
  2. Strength of evidence. FDA-approved or FDA-monograph actives (like minoxidil or ketoconazole) rank above ingredients supported by a single small trial.
  3. Formulation and tolerability. Fragrance, known irritants, pH, and texture, plus how suitable the product is for sensitive skin.
  4. Value. Cost per month of use, not just sticker price.
  5. Real-world feedback. Patterns across a large volume of verified buyer reviews, especially complaints about irritation or quality.
  6. Brand transparency. Clear ingredient lists, honest claims, and third-party testing where relevant (especially for supplements).

How our scores work

On our "Best … for …" guides, every product is scored out of 10 on the same set of criteria, chosen for that specific need. For example, our guide to shampoos for thinning hair weighs evidence for thinning hair at 40%, suitability for fine hair at 25%, gentleness at 15%, and value at 20%. Each guide publishes its criteria and weights in a "How we score" section.

  • The overall score is calculated from the sub-scores and weights. It isn't typed in by hand.
  • Products are ranked strictly by score. Our publishing system won't let a guide go live if the order doesn't match the scores.
  • Evidence is scored on a fixed scale: 9–10 for FDA-approved or guideline-recommended options with multiple randomized trials; 7–8 for at least one controlled clinical study; 4–6 for products that support a related outcome without direct evidence; 1–3 for marketing claims only.
  • Commission plays no part in any score or ranking.

Scores are our editorial judgment on those criteria, not customer ratings.

Ingredient guides

"What's inside" links on product cards lead to our Ingredient Library. Each ingredient guide covers what the ingredient is, how it works, what the evidence supports and doesn't, how to use it, and side effects. Every claim is sourced from systematic reviews, clinical trials, government health agencies, or professional medical bodies.

What our reviews are not

Unless an article explicitly says we tested a product hands-on, our picks are based on the research process above, not personal use or lab testing. We'll never imply otherwise. As we grow, we plan to add hands-on testing and will mark those reviews clearly.

How affiliate links fit in

Some product links earn us a commission. A product's commission rate plays no part in whether it's included or where it ranks, and we include products we earn nothing from when they're the best option. See our affiliate disclosure.